Many individual stones and fragments of this meteorite were recovered in township 25, range 30E., in Union County, New Mexico, which is a very arid region. The total recovered weight was 44.4 kg.
The L-chondrite parent body experienced a catastrophic breakup event 470 (±6) m.y. ago. This refined age estimate was determined by utilizing multiple 40Ar39Ar isochrons to successfully resolve the various trapped components and then correct for any excess Ar (Korochantseva et al., 2007). In another study, the ArAr chronometry of maskelynite present in the L impact melt rock NWA 11042 was investigated by Váci et al. (2020). They obtained a highly precise age of 484.0 (±1.5) m.y., which is ~15 m.y. older than the ages derived from previous studies. While it is possible this age reflects additional uncertainty in the underlying data, it otherwise represents either an earlier impact that formed the maskelynite, or the actual timing of the catastrophic breakup of the L parent body.
In an effort to more accurately date the L-chondrite parent body breakup, Liao et al. (2020) employed U-corrected UPb chronometry to date volcanic zircons associated with three ash-bearing horizons of the Hällekis quarry at Kinnekulle, Sweden: HKIS 2a, HKIS 4c, and Likhall (in order of increasing depth/age). Having calculated the depositional ages for the three ash-bearing layers, especially the lowest/oldest Likhall bed with a weighted mean age of 465.01 (±0.26) m.y., and combining this data with an improved sedimentation rate, they were able to date the stratigraphic layer associated with the L-chondrite parent body breakup. The exact position of this layer within the Hällekis-Thorsberg section was previously ascertained to be 1.0 m below the base of the Arkeologen bed based on Os-isotopic, chromite, and biostratigraphic data along with an extraterrestrial 3He anomaly. Incorporating all of this information, they derived a more precise age for the L-chondrite parent body breakup of 465.76 (±0.30) m.y.
This violent planetesimal breakup resulted in the loss of a primordial gas component, after which a period of slow cooling ensued which may be indicative of its re-accretion into a rubble-pile asteroid. Evidence attesting to this disruption has been found in the form of a high abundance of relict fossil meteorites (101 found to date; Schmitz et al., 2014) in mid-Ordovician marine (seafloor) limestone quarries, including the Thorsberg (e.g., Österplana), Hällekis, and Gullhögen quarries in southern Sweden, and the Gäde quarry in central Sweden (e.g., Brunflo). Sediment-dispersed extraterrestrial chromite grains have been found in these quarries, as well as in coincident sediment beds from the Puxi River in south-central China and the Lynna River in Russia; some of these chromite grains have been demonstrated to be regolith-derived (Meier et al., 2013).
It was ascertained that the elemental and O-isotopic compositions of the surviving chromite grains from the fossil meteorites were most consistent with an L-group chondritic parent body, and remnant chondrule abundances, textures, and mean diameters are consistent with this finding (Bridges et al., 2007 and references therein). The O-isotopic composition of the sediment-dispersed extraterrestrial chromite grains was determined by Heck et al. (2009) through a SIMS study. Measurements of several fossil meteorites, along with numerous chromite grains obtained from various quarries, have oxygen three-isotope values most consistent with modern L chondrites, but overlap with LL chondrites. The size range of the chromite grains was established on the parent body by means of varying degrees of metamorphism, and this range was shown to have a direct correspondence to the petrologic type of the fossil meteorites as follows:
Chromite Diameter vs.
Although this method of discrimination among petrologic types is not absolute, it serves to illustrate the approximate range of petrologic types represented by the fossil meteorites from the mid-Ordovician Swedish marine limestone quarries. It was determined that a greater percentage of low petrologic types are present in the quarries compared to the percentages represented by recent L-chondrite falls, possibly reflecting differences in the nature of the ejected material (Bridges et al., 2007).
Utilizing a new method to resolve the chondrite group to which these fossil meteorites derive, Alwmark and Schmitz (2009) studied relict chromite grains from fossil meteorites recovered in the Thorsberg quarry (Österplana) and Gärde quarry (Brunflo), as well as grains recovered from sediment samples from similar quarries. They studied <115 µm-sized olivine, pyroxene, and other inclusion types that are encapsulated in chromite grains, and discovered that for many of these mineral inclusions the primary compositions have been retained, thus enabling these chromite inclusions to be employed as an additional classification method. Despite the fact that extensive sub-solidus re-equilibration of these silicate inclusions has occurred over hundreds of thousands of years, resulting in their having a higher content of Cr and a lower Fe/Mg ratio, a comparison was still able to be made between these relict inclusions and analogous inclusions in chromite grains from recent chondrites. It was demonstrated that the Fa and Fs values associated with the fossil chromite host meteorite are all consistent with an L chondrite heritage. Moreover, Heck et al. (2009) found that the elemental compositions of the chromite grains they analyzed were consistent with those of modern L chondrites.
The age of the meteorites found in these quarries has been precisely established in accord with the Geologic Time Scale 2004 to be 467.3 (±1.6) m.y., based on the appearance of certain species of early marine conodonts. In addition, an anomalously high volume of extraterrestrial chromite grains was found during a search of sediments within this 3.2 m stratigraphic interval. This interval represents 12 m.y. of accumulation, and the initial count indicated a 100-fold increase in the meteorite flux during this specific period (Schmitz et al., 2003). A subsequent thorough study was conducted at the Vernadsky Institute in Russia (V. A. Alexeev, 2014) to ascertain the abundances of both extraterrestrial and terrestrial sediment-dispersed chromite grains that are present in these stratigraphic layers at the various quarries. The results indicate that the actual increase in extraterrestrial chromite grains compared to those of terrestrial origin was only a factor of ~34.
In 2001, workers at the Thorsberg quarry discovered a single fossil meteorite, designated Gla3 003 and measuring 8 × 6.5 × 2 cm, that was located in the uppermost bed; this meteorite was different from all of the other L-chondrite fossils (Schmitz et al., 2014, 2016). This fossil meteorite, classified as Österplana 065 (previously designated 'the mysterious object'), was initially determined to be most similar to winonaites, although it had a number of unique characteristics. Its O-isotopic value plots along the trend for winonaites which suggests formation within a common reservoir, and its elemental ratios compare reasonably well with this group as well. Notably, a xenolithic inclusion from the L6 chondrite Villalbeto de la Peña shares similar isotopic and compositional characteristics with this unusual fossil meteorite. Schmitz et al. (2016) conducted Cr-isotopic analyses of Österplana 065, three fossil L chondrites (Österplana 018, 029, and 032), and the Villalbeto de la Peña clast, as well as chrome-spinel grains from both the winonaite NWA 725 and the L6 chondrite Lundsgard. In addition, they determined more precise oxygen isotopes for chrome-spinel grains from Österplana 065. They demonstrated through a coupled Δ17O vs. ε54Cr diagram (shown below) that Österplana 065 plots in a distinct location in isotope space, indicating that it derives from a unique, possibly extinct parent body not otherwise represented in our collections. In addition, it was shown that the Villalbeto de la Peña clast plots with NWA 725 in the winonaite field.
Österplana 065 Chromium vs. Oxygen Isotope Plot
click on image for a magnified view
Diagram credit: Schmitz, B. et al., Nature Communications, vol. 7, p. 4 (2016, open accesslink) 'A new type of solar-system material recovered from Ordovician marine limestone'
Österplana 065 has the same gas retention age as the other L chondrites of 470 m.y., and its CRE age of ~1 m.y. matches that of chromite grains derived from the fossil L chondrites from the same uppermost stratum in the quarry. The chrome-spinel grains in Österplana 065 exhibit abundant planar shock features comparable to chromite in some highly shocked L chondrites with a shock stage of S4S6 (Rout et al., 2017, 2018). These facts along with other evidence indicate that Österplana 065 is likely associated with the same catastrophic breakup event as the L6 chondrites, and it was conjectured that this unique meteorite could represent the impactor that disrupted the L chondrite parent body 470 m.y. ago. Interestingly, Martin and Schmitz (2016) have identified a chrome-spinel grain that has an elemental composition similar to chrome spinel grains from the Österplana 065 fossil meteorite. This grain was among over 500 extraterrestrial grains collected and analyzed from 100 kg of rock obtained from the Komstad Limestone Formation in Killeröd, Scania, Sweden; this location has proven to be exceptionally rich in chromite grains associated with the L-chondrite breakup event. Heck et al. (2017 [#1694]) conducted a further study of relict grains deposited in sediments at the Lynna River in Russia 467 m.y. ago (prior to the L-chondrite breakup event). Employing a coupled Δ17O vs. TiO2 diagram, they identified a single chrome-spinel grain which plots in compositional space similar to Österplana 065.
A significant number of chromite grains recovered from the Sextummen bed at the Thorsberg Quarry were found to contain solar-wind-implanted Ne and He (Meier et al., 2008). This finding provides positive evidence that the chromite grains did not permeate the meteorite before its delivery to Earth only to be released into the limestone sediments by the action of terrestrial weathering processes. Instead, the chromite grains were established initially as particles comprising one to several ~100-µm-sized grains at the time of parent body breakup, becoming solar gas rich during their rapid transit and delivery to Earth (Heck et al., 2008). Studies of chromite grains from contemporary mid-Ordovician limestone beds in both China (Alwmark et al., 2012) and northwestern Russia (Lindskog et al., 2012) have demonstrated that the same high concentrations exist and contain similar implanted solar Ne, attesting to a global accretion from the breakup of the L-chondrite parent body ~470 m.y. ago.
Cosmic ray exposure age measurements of the fossil meteorites based on cosmogenic 21Ne indicate that their ages correspond to their recovered depth within the sediment, with longer CRE ages found in the younger strata (Heck et al., 2004; see diagram below). It was determined that these meteorite samples arrived on Earth within one hundred thousand to hundreds of thousands of years after parent body breakup. By considering both solar and galactic cosmic-rays, a very approximate 21Ne-based CRE age was calculated for the chromite grains, with an age of 0.0469.6 m.y. considered as the best estimate. Extensive analyses of cosmogenic noble gases in these chromite grains, when compared to those in fossil meteorites recovered from similar quarries, have demonstrated that the CRE ages are comparable and significantly lower than those of recently fallen L chondrites.
Thorsberg Quarry Fossil L ChondritesCRE age vs. Depth
Diagram credit: Schmitz et al., Science Advances, vol. 5, #9, (18 Sep 2019, open accesslink)
'An extraterrestrial trigger for the mid-Ordovician ice age: Dust from the breakup of the L-chondrite parent body'
New high-resolution dating techniques utilizing chrome spinel and both He and Os isotopes were employed by Schmitz et al. (2019). They determined the exact stratigraphic level associated with the arrival of µm-sized meteoritic dust in marine limestone at the Hällekis-Thorsberg Quarry in southern Sweden, and at the Lynna River site near St. Petersburg, Russia. Importantly, at this stratigraphic level L-chondrite grains begin to dominate over H- and LL-chondrite grains, whereas prior to this all three groups had approximately equal abundances. As indicated by each of these parameters, the onset of meteoritic dust deposition occurs at 1 m below the base of the Arkeologen bed. Notably, this timing is simultaneous with the arrival of larger chromite grains and micrometeorites from the L-chondrite asteroid. Accordingly, the collisional breakup must have occurred close to an orbital resonance allowing for a rapid delivery to Earth of all material regardless of size.
Bottke et al. (2009) argued that a catastrophic breakup of an asteroid would have rapidly injected fragments into a nearby strong orbital resonance such as the Jupiter 5:2 mean motion resonance at ~2.82 AU, which would provide very short transit times from the inner asteroid belt to Earth in a matter of 50 t.y. to 2 m.y. According to their model, recent delivery of this shocked L chondrite material from the main belt to Earth-crossing orbits would occur through the more efficient Jupiter 3:1 mean motion resonance in 5100 m.y. (most in 3040 m.y.). In addition, orbital decay via the PoyntingRobertson drag mechanism would likely assist the rapid transit of chromite dust grains to Earth (Heck et al., 2008). An increase in the cratering rate on Earth at this time may be apparent, but crater ages need to be better resolved before a definite association can be established. Schmitz et al. (2019) consider it plausible that the relatively sudden onset of the mid-Ordovician ice age was caused by, or at least aided by the meteoritic dust associated with the breakup of the L-chondrite parent body. The dust would have partially occluded sunlight both in Earth's atmosphere and in local interplanetary space. In addition, they propose that the Great Ordovician Biodiversification Event (GOBE) is related to this catastrophic breakup. This is exemplified by shallow-water fauna replacing deep-water fauna observed in the Täljsten lowstand unit located just above the onset of L-chondrite dust, and similarly across multiple paleocontinents, which attests to falling sea levels due to glacial ice production.
Although the Gefion family was once considered a plausible source of L chondrites due to the timing of breakup and to its proximity to efficient resonances, recent VNIR spectra of 11 Gefion family asteroids show that a mixture of chondrite types are present (Roberts et al., 2015). In a subsequent NIR spectral study of five Gefion family asteroids, McGraw et al. (2017) employed laboratory spectral calibrations to ascertain that two of them (1839 Ragazza and 2521 Heidi) have silicate compositions similar to H-chondrites, two of them (2386 Nikonov and 3860 Plovdiv) are similar to an acapulcoitelodranite-like primitive achondrite, and one (2373 Immo) is similar to an HED-like basaltic achondrite.
Based on new noble gas and cosmogenic nuclide analyses as well as dynamical modeling, Meier et al. (2017) assert that the location of the L chondrite parent body at the time of breakup was near the Jupiter 5:2 mean motion resonance (signifying the ratio between the orbital period of Jupiter and that of an asteroid) from which rapid delivery from the inner asteroid belt to an Earth-crossing orbit could be attained, consistent with the CRE age calculated for the fossil L chondrites recovered from mid-Ordovician limestone quarries. Based on spectrographic and mineralogical data for more than 1,000 near-Earth asteroids, Binzel et al. (2016) determined the probable main belt source region for each of the ordinary chondrite groups (see diagram below).
Diagram credit: Binzel et al., 47th LPSC, #1352 (2016)
Thereafter, L chondrite material would have been delivered to the more efficient, albeit slower, 3:1 mean motion resonance at 2.50 AU (and the less important ν6 secular resonance) where transfer to Earth occurred over an extended period of millions of years. In consideration of such factors as pre-breakup size, breakup age, and shock-darkening history of the parent asteroid, they contend that the Ino asteroid family may be a more plausible source than the Gefion family (see the Park Forest page for further details). In another study, Gaffey and Fieber-Beyer (2019) contend that the large Massalia asteroid family meets many requirements as the source of L chondrites, and a spectral investigation of members of this asteroid family is underway.
Diagram credit: Meier et al., MAPS, vol. 52, p. 1569 (2017)
'Park Forest (L5) and the asteroidal source of shocked L chondrites'
At least one further impact event on the L-chondrite parent body is recorded ~20 m.y. ago, which produced abundant fragments and caused severe shock effects and significant radiogenic gas loss. A portion of the fragments eventually found their way into Earth-crossing resonances, and they are currently one of the most well represented meteorite groups seen to fall. The specimen of Beenham shown above is a 29.0 g partial slice with a large troilite inclusion at its center.